HotelsForKings scores are editorial judgments against our published criteria, informed by a synthesis of recent verified guest reviews and documented facilities. How we score.
The legend is older than the upkeep. Recent guests flag rooms and fittings showing wear, the odd maintenance lapse, and no on-site restaurant or bar. Come for the address, the lobby, and the design history; price-check against newer Midtown rooms before you commit, because the rate sometimes outruns the condition.
The Royalton Hotel at 44 West 44th Street was redesigned by Ian Schrager and Philippe Starck in 1988 and in doing so created the template for the Midtown boutique hotel category that the Mercer, the Ace, and every subsequent New York boutique has operated within. The lobby, the sunken seating, the specific lighting, the social configuration of a room designed for looking and being looked at, anticipated the lobby-as-social-destination concept by two decades.
The 168 rooms were reworked in 2007 by Roman and Williams, who kept the signatures worth keeping, the round "disco" tubs and the wood-burning fireplaces in select rooms, and set them against a darker, warmer palette of slate and low light. It reads less as a 1988 time capsule than as a considered second act built on Starck's bones.
The Royalton's 44th Street position between 5th and 6th Avenues places it on the block that connects Times Square to the public library, midway between the Theatre District and the Bryant Park cultural corridor. The lobby has remained the hotel's primary social space through every operational iteration, still capturing the cross-industry Midtown crowd that Schrager's original programme attracted.
For guests who want the boutique hotel category's origin story rather than its current iterations, the Royalton provides the 1988 design at a rate that reflects the building's age relative to the surrounding luxury towers.
The 44th Street position and the lobby's accumulated reputation as a Midtown meeting venue make the Royalton a business hotel for guests whose client relationships were established in the 1990s and early 2000s and for whom the hotel's name carries professional resonance. The design intelligence remains.
The round disco tub, the wood-burning fireplace in select rooms, and the lobby's enduring social scene give a solo stay genuine character, the sense of a hotel built by someone with strong opinions. For a work week in Midtown that wants some design history in the room, the Royalton delivers it at a rate well below the surrounding glass towers.
From $250/night; suites from $500/night. Check availability at royaltonhotel.com.
More exceptional options in the same city.
Browse all New York hotels by occasion.
New openings, special offers, and the week’s best value suites. One email a week, no noise.
