Ocean Key Resort & Spa is our top Key West pick for couples who want to walk out the door into Old Town: about 100 rooms and suites at 0 Duval Street, with the Sunset Pier bar built over the water and the Hot Tin Roof restaurant on the marina. Book a Gulf-facing suite for the sunset; expect Duval noise and a resort fee near 67.50 dollars a night.
Editorial aggregate 9.2/10, our own assessment across Room & Design, Service and Location. This is our opinion, not a user-review average. See how we rate properties in our methodology.
Location is the whole argument. Ocean Key Resort & Spa sits at 0 Duval Street, the exact point where Key West's most famous street runs out of island and meets the Gulf, right beside Mallory Square. No other hotel on the island puts you closer to the nightly Sunset Celebration, the Duval bar crawl and the cruise pier without leaving your own deck. Managed by Noble House Resorts, it holds roughly 100 rooms and suites that face either the water or the Old Town streetscape, with local art, bright fabrics and, in the upper categories, private balconies and in-room spa tubs. A note for planners: older listings describe this as an all-suite property, but the current room chart runs from a standard guestroom and a partial ocean-view queen up through boutique and one-bedroom suites to an oceanfront penthouse, so it is a mix rather than suites only.
Book a Gulf-facing room or suite, and treat the water view as the point of the whole stay. A west-facing balcony over the marina is the single reason to choose Ocean Key over its Old Town rivals, and it earns the premium over a city-view room, which looks onto the busy streetscape and loses the address's best asset. Suites that add a separate living area and an in-room spa tub suit a proposal or an anniversary. Skip the lowest city-view categories unless price is the only lever you have, because you are paying waterfront rates without the water. Light sleepers should ask for a higher floor set back from the Sunset Pier stage, where the live music runs latest.
Three outlets cover the day, and all three are current. The Sunset Pier is a casual bar and grill built out over the water at the foot of the resort, open for lunch, dinner, cocktails and live music, and it remains one of the best places in Key West to be at sundown. Hot Tin Roof, raised above the marina, handles breakfast and dinner and holds its own as an island dinner destination independent of the hotel, with a Conch-fusion menu and water views. The LIQUID Pool Bar and Lounge covers poolside drinks and light bites, and a smaller waterfront bar rounds out the drinking options. You can eat every meal here without it feeling like a compromise, though Duval Street's wider dining scene starts a two-minute walk away if you want variety.
It has a spa but not a beach. The boutique SpaTerre spa leans into Balinese and Thai rituals and is a genuine reason to slow down between the bars and the boat trips, though it is small enough that treatment slots go quickly in high season, partly because cruise passengers book in too, so reserve ahead. The pool and marina-front deck are pleasant and social rather than expansive, with live music by the water some evenings. Set expectations clearly: this is a waterfront town hotel, not a beach resort, so the pool is the swimming and the mood is lively rather than serene. Key West has very little natural sand anywhere. If a beach matters to your trip, look at the sibling Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton, which holds the island's largest private beach at the quieter southern end.
A proposal here has a specific logistical advantage: the Sunset Pier is the island's most scenic waterfront venue for the question, available to hotel guests without the reservation gymnastics of a standalone restaurant. Time a Gulf-facing suite, a pier table and the champagne to sunset, coordinate a photographer with the concierge, and most of the choreography sorts itself out. It is the reason we tag Ocean Key for proposals over its quieter Old Town rivals. The one thing to manage is the crowd: the same sunset that makes the moment also draws the Mallory Square gathering next door, so a pier table gives you the view with a little separation from the throng.
The two headline Key West resorts split on a single question: do you want the party at your door or the beach under your feet? Ocean Key is the on-Duval, on-the-water choice, built for couples who want Old Town and the Sunset Pier a step away. Casa Marina Key West, a Curio Collection by Hilton hotel we recently rebuilt, is Henry Flagler's 1920 grande dame at the quiet beach end of the island, with the largest private beach in Key West and a calmer, more spread-out feel. Pick honestly against how you actually spend a trip, not against the photographs.
| Hotel | Best for | Setting |
|---|---|---|
| Ocean Key Resort & Spa | Proposals, nightlife, sunset over the water | Foot of Duval / Mallory Square, no beach, Noble House |
| Casa Marina Key West | Beach days, families, a calmer base | Quiet south end, private beach, Curio Collection by Hilton |
| The Marquesa Hotel | Quiet Old Town charm, a few blocks off Duval | 27-room Victorian, garden, Cafe Marquesa |
Key West International Airport (EYW) is about three miles and a ten to fifteen minute drive from the hotel, with connections through Miami and other Florida hubs. Many visitors instead drive the Overseas Highway (US-1) down the island chain from Miami, which takes roughly three-and-a-half to four hours and is a genuine part of the trip. Once you are in Old Town you will not need a car, which is fortunate because parking here is tight and valet runs around 50 dollars a day on top of the resort fee; Duval Street, Mallory Square and the main sights are all within walking distance. On timing, winter into spring (December to April) is high season, with the best weather, the highest rates and events that fill the island, while summer and autumn fall inside the June-to-November Atlantic hurricane season, which brings heat, the odd storm and the lowest prices. The shoulders, May and late autumn, tend to give the best balance of weather and value for this hotel.
Four drawbacks are worth knowing before you book. First, the location cuts both ways: being at the foot of Duval and beside Mallory Square means crowds, live music and street noise, at their loudest as everyone gathers for the sunset, so light sleepers should request a higher room set back from the pier. Second, cruise-ship days: Mallory Square and the nearby pier can flood with day-trippers, and the SpaTerre spa in particular gets busy with visitors who are not even staying here. Third, the cost stacks up: rates commonly start around the high-300s and climb well past that in winter, and a resort fee near 67.50 dollars plus tax is added per night, valet on top. Fourth, there is no natural beach, which is true of Key West generally but still surprises first-timers; if a beach is central to your trip, book Casa Marina instead. And the practical one for anyone here in late summer: this is peak hurricane season, so travel insurance and a flexible rate are sensible.
We may earn a commission from bookings, at no extra cost to you. It never affects our ranking.
No. Despite older listings that call it all-suite, Ocean Key is a mix of about 100 guest rooms and suites, from a standard guestroom and a partial ocean-view queen up to boutique suites, one-bedroom suites and an oceanfront penthouse. Higher categories add separate living areas, private balconies and in-room spa tubs, and there is no true budget entry point.
It sits at 0 Duval Street, at the very end of Duval where the street meets the water, beside Mallory Square in Old Town. That puts the nightly Mallory Square Sunset Celebration, the shops and bars of Duval, and the cruise pier within a short walk, which is the location's great strength and the source of its noise and crowds.
Yes. Ocean Key charges a resort fee of about 67.50 US dollars per room, per night on top of the room rate, and valet parking runs roughly 50 dollars a day. Factor both into any price comparison with other Key West hotels, because the headline nightly rate is not the whole cost.
Hot Tin Roof is the marina-view restaurant for breakfast and dinner, the Sunset Pier is the casual waterfront bar and grill built out over the water for lunch, dinner, drinks and live music, and the LIQUID Pool Bar and Lounge handles poolside drinks and light bites. The Sunset Pier is one of the best places on the island to watch the sun go down.
No. Ocean Key is a waterfront town hotel with a pool and a marina-front deck, not a beach resort, so the pool is the swimming. Key West has very little natural sand generally. If a beach is central to your trip, the sibling Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton, has the island's largest private beach at the quieter southern end.
It is one of the strongest proposal addresses in Key West because the Sunset Pier gives hotel guests a scenic waterfront setting at sunset without the reservation complexity of a standalone restaurant. Pair a Gulf-facing suite with a pier table timed to sunset and the logistics largely take care of themselves.
Key West International Airport (EYW) is about three miles and roughly a ten to fifteen minute drive from the hotel, with connections through Miami and other Florida hubs. Many visitors instead drive the Overseas Highway from Miami, which takes about three-and-a-half to four hours. Once in Old Town you will not need a car.
More top Key West options if Ocean Key is not the right fit.
New city guides, occasion picks, and rate alerts, weekly.